
Man there are a ton of cat litter choices out there! Choosing a litter at a pet store has become a daunting task. Clumping or not? Crystals? Perfumed or no? Litter that changes color? My cats are not terribly picky when it comes to litter so I’ve tried a few to see what worked best for all of us. From cleaning, to smell, texture (a big thing for many cats) and clumpability. The following is my personal experience with a variety of cat litter — what worked (and failed) for me, may not work with your cat — but it might save you some money from trying the multitudes of litter out there.
1) Plain clay litter (non-clumping)
This litter is usually very dusty (I’ll admit some clumping litter can be dusty but not quite as bad in my experience). Because the litter doesn’t clump it makes it difficult to clean out urine. The urine usually settles in the bottom of the pan and you end up scraping out a ton of clean litter with the soiled litter. However, some cats prefer the texture of clay litter on their toesies — you just have to know your cat.
2) Tidy Cat
I have used the regular, multi cat, immediate odor control, and long lasting odor control formulas. This litter clumps okay but seems to break apart easily when you are scooping it. It also seems to stick to the bottom of the box and become a concrete like paste, that’s nearly impossible to scrape out.
3) Tidy Cat Small Spaces
Compared to regular tidy cat the “small space” formula is at least $2-3 more for the same amount of litter. It does seem to do pretty well on covering smells, but the clumps still break apart and again it turns to the grey paste in the corner of the box. It also has a strong perfume odor, so if your cat doesn’t like perfumed litter (and alot cats don’t) this is not the litter for you.
4) Arm and Hammer Litter
I haven’t used this litter in a couple of years so I admit I’m a little hazy on it. From what I remember, it took care of litterbox smells pretty well, but didn’t clump all that well.
5) Feline Pine
This litter looks like small sticks (kinda like pretzel sticks). It dissolves, when it gets wet, into a saw-dust like material. My main complaints about this litter is the smell — it smells like a pine tree (duh!) and then when you add urine and feces you get a funky litrine+forest smell. Mmm…reminds me of Girl Scouts! Not to mention alot of cats do NOT like loud smelling litter — its sort of a litterbox turn off.
Also, my cat seemed to collect the saw dust like particles in between her pads and then deposited them throughout the house.
On good notes, the litter is virtually dust free, contains no added chemicals or artificial fragrances.
6) Crystal litter
This litter basically dehydrates the urine. However, to do its “magic” the litter makes a slight hissing sound when urine hits it. As most cats don’t think hissing = happiness, many cats will not use this litter. I guess its sort of like little kids and automatic flush toilets — they think the toilet is going to suck them in. So I guess cats think the litter is angry at them.
7) Fre
sh Step UNSCENTED
I LOVE THIS LITTER! The clumping factor of this litter is excellent and I love that it is unscented. My cats seem to like how it feels on their toes. It also controls litter box smells pretty well (hey…no litter is perfect).
Helpful Hint:
Ben gets the credit for this one: If you have a deep enough litterbox, put about 5 inches of litter in the box. This seems like a huge amount (its about 1 box of litter). However, it makes it so the urine clumps on top instead of allowing it to flow to the bottom, and then soak in the plastic. It makes cleaning out the litterbox much easier and it gives the cat more litter to paw through. (That’s if you have a kitty that actually covers their poop — must be nice!)